Samsung Intrepid Review
November 27, 2009 – 10:31 am | Comments

This is a review of the Samsung Intrepid from Sprint.  Overall, I liked the phone.  It has a good build, and the software is impressive.  There were a few quirks here and there though.  …

Read the full story »
Home » Opinion

HTC Touch HD Thoughts – Part #1

closeThis post was published 9 months 27 days ago which may make its actuality or expire date not be valid anymore. This site is not responsible for any misunderstanding.

“Today, for a few hours, I held perfection in my hands… “

G. Bouhnick, Feb 02, 2009

(OK, that’s actually me quoting myself…)

It happened when a colleague of mine was kind enough to let me play with his bran new toy: the HTC Touch HD! (Thanks again Dean!)

HD_Wolverine

HTC Touch HD. Even the name sounds impressive…

(I think HD Stands for: “Huge Device!”, or “Ho my god I must have this Device!” or maybe: “Hey Dean! Can I borrow your phone for a year?”)

I will start my review by saying:

This is the best Windows Mobile device I have ever tried.

True, I didn’t had a chance to check battery life or GPS, so I’m not sure I can even call it a “review”, but I did manage to learn a few things about the quality of the manliest gadget for 2008, and I have some thoughts about it (I will split them into 2 parts)

hd_transformers

Design:

When they invented the term “cutting edge” – Touch HD was in front of their eyes, I’m sure!

Black colored, slim, elegant, the edges are a bit cut (I told you this is cutting edge), huge display – perfection.

The device feels great in the hand too. It’s not so rounded and thin as the slippery iPhone – so it actually feels much better in the hand.

The back cover of it is nice, and feels classy. High end.

It is without a doubt, the best looking device I’ve ever seen. (well, maybe second best after the Palm Pre…)Hardware Buttons:

Finally, HTC got rid of the catastrophic Diamond/Pro D-Pad in favor of much better hardware buttons:

The on/off button (top/right), and the volume buttons (left) are located exactly like the iPhone buttons (nothing unusual there).

But unlike the iPhone, that has just one ‘Home’ button, the HD has 4 hardware buttons: Send, End, Home and Back.

I’m mentioning this because in my previous iPhone thoughts, I wrote about the lack of ‘Send’ button that makes it hard to easily launch calls.

The HD has the answer for that. When you click on the ‘Send’ button, your calls log is presented with a nice dial pad beneath it.

Untitled-4

Of course, HTC wanted to spice things up a little so those hardware buttons are actually inside a touch surface with a haptic feedback that feels pretty nice.

Another thing worth mentioning is that the Back button acts also as an ‘OK’ button for dialogs which has OK button on the top.

There’s no physical D-Pad (instead, there’s 4 arrows buttons in the virtual keyboard), but as one of my friends mentioned: when you own a Diamond you get used to not using the D-Pad at all, and with the finger gestures scrolling capabilities – it’s easy to navigate without a D-Pad.

Screen Display:

WVGA. (That’s wide, really wide VGA).

It’s actually longer than the iPhone or any other device I know.

HD

There has been a lot of complains about the low sensitivity of the Diamond / Pro / Fuze devices (there are some tweaks that slightly improve this problem).

HD has a completely different screen which feels very soft and sensitive exactly as a Windows Mobile device should. This is yet another great improvement over the earlier HTC Touch devices.

Finger Friendliness

It’s common to complain about the lack of finger friendly UI in Windows Mobile.

HTC made a lot of enhancements to the standard OS with the TouchFlo 3D, finger scrollable lists, bigger menus, etc.

The nice thing about the Touch HD is that the screen display is so big, that it effects the sizes of the buttons, tabs, and menus – they are all much bigger, which makes the device more finger friendly.

(still, there are those old settings windows which requires a stylus or a fingernail, or… claws???…)

claws

Virtual Keyboard:

When I just tested the Diamond, I just couldn’t use the virtual keyboard – the small keys size and the screen sensitivity made it really hard for me to type.

The size of the HD’s screen plus the great sensitivity turns the keyboard into something that actually works fine.

Performance:

Another problematic area in previous HTC devices was the performance. Here, as well, there has been some tweaks to improve the speed of the TouchFlo 3D, but guess what: there’s no need for that in the Touch HD. This thing simply rocks!

No more lags while switching between TouchFlo tabs, no more waiting for windows to open up. This thing flies!

TouchFlo 3D

Once the TouchFlo works quickly (as it should), it’s really fun!

hdstocks

The HD version of the TouchFlo is working extremely smooth. It also has few additions to the version of the Touch Diamond/Pro/Fuze such as an additional tab for stocks, some extra buttons in the People tab and some new configuration capabilities.

What’s Wrong?

I think I just wrote too many good things to say about the Touch HD: Amazing design, huge VGA screen with great sensitivity, good performance, and more.

You all know I complain a lot; I got bored quickly by the BlackBerry, I didn’t like the Diamond from the first moment, I found some issues with the Pro (managed to solve many of them), and I still find it hard to get used to the iPhone’s missing features

So… what about the HD?

Well, that’s a tough question…

I guess I can throw the obvious weak points:

- Lack of physical keyboard

- WinMo historical diseases

- Missing TouchFlo features (e.g. adding Today plug-ins etc.)

I can also complain about the image zoom feature which works extremely slow.

But the truth is that at this point, I cannot put my finger on a serious weakness in the Touch HD.

As I said at the beginning of my post, I suspect that the Touch HD is the best Windows Mobile handset out there.

(Treo Pro/Sony Ericsson XPeria/Samsung Omnia owners – I invite you to argue with the above statement…)

To be continued…

Post to Twitter Post to Yahoo Buzz Post to Delicious Post to Digg Post to Facebook

Rate Post

Worthless PostNot that goodAverage PostGood PostSuper Post (3 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5) -

Similar Posts

Gil Bouhnick (59 Posts) - Website | Twitter | Facebook

Gil Bouhnick is a guest writer at MobilitySite and the owner of The Mobile Spoon. He is a Director of Mobile Solutions at ClickSoftware, running ClickSoftware's MobileFever, and constantly trying to examine new mobile trends and technologies.


You can also participate in other conversation in our active forums with 200,000 other Members. It only takes 2 minutes to sign up one time for free in the forums.


  • digger
    If you're willing to use the HD with an EDGE connection rather than a 3G connection, you can use it with service from T-Mobile and AT&T. That's what I'm doing here on the Left Coast.

    "But EDGE isn't as fast as 3G" I hear you say. When you've never used either, EDGE is plenty fast. So I can't use it to watch video -- how often am I actually going to do that anyway?
  • caveman
    Hate to ruin it for all of ya, but the HTC HD is NOT coming to the U.S. This was spoken from the horses mouth. HTC said that they cannot configure the phone's 3G access quick enough. By the time they did, the HD would be too late to make a big impact.

    I have heard that they are going to use the shell (read: hardware) as a handset for the next Google phone running Android. Is it true? check the blogs.

    I'm super bummed about this too as I was really looking forward to getting a HD, but alas, no 3G support means only hooking up to wireless hotspots. A little too limited for me.

    Peace.
  • digger
    I've been carrying an HD since December, it's pretty much replaced my trusty old Dell Axim as my PDA and my old LG phone.

    I've found a a few things wrong, and here's what I've done to correct them:

    I did a lot of "butt dialing" at first. I finally turned off TouchFlo3D and went back to the standard WM Today screen. I'm a lot happier now that I can simply touch "Lock device" on the Today screen and not call my wife randomly.

    The camera leaves a lot to be desired. It's slow and doesn't work well in low light levels. I wanted to like it, but I've pretty much given up on it.

    Finally, you can't control which network connection your applications use. I switched from the included RSS reader to BeyondPod because the latter lets me specify not to use the EDGE connection to download podcasts. I wish I could control that at the device level -- I don't need to use up my data bandwidth when I'm connected to a WiFi network.

    Other than those three things, I'm loving this device.
  • phreaker18
    Well if i get an unexpected bonus which im expecting :P .. im getting this device and the Nokia N97 can wait !!
  • Thanks for this Gil ... it was terrific!
  • I have been reading about and lusting for the HTC HD for almost 6 months. My frustration grows daily as I read about Europe, Asia,and even Australia getting this device. Here in America we are forced to sit by and wait.

    Being with ATT, I refuse to "upgrade" my HTC 8125 to the FUZE. Not much of an upgrade if you ask me. With Barcelona around the corner, maybe the announcement I've been waiting for is not far behind.

    Signed,

    HIGHLY FRUSTRATED
  • Keisha Barwise
    I also had the opportunity to play with the Touch HD over my christmas break, and i won’t argue with you that its the best WM device out there currently, save for the lack of physical keyboard.

    But its biggest fault to me is it still running Windows Mobile.

    The browsing experience is remarkably better than say on the 8525, which is understandable for a 2.8” device, and no complaints in the speed department.

    But the $800 price point is kind of restrictive. It’s a really nice device if you can afford it.

    A nice addition is Gyrator and i think there's another one called GSensor. They use the HD's accelerometer, and makes the HD and any other accelerometer enabled phone, change orientation as you move it.

    The configuration interface isn't the greatest but its relatively unobstrusive. Definitely good addition to HD users.

    Just remembered a gripe, skyfire hasn't released a wvga version yet, so no skyfire on the HD.
  • I am pleased to see that your opinion is along the same lines as mine.

    One area I found could be improved was substituting TouchFlo 3D with SPB Mobile Shell to allow me more flexibility in screens. Apart from that I loaded up a few programmes such as FlexMail, Evernote and PockeTwit and am completely happy with the best WM phone out there.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Post Navigation