Palm Pre Plus, Palm Pixi Plus — Review

Posted by Dan H. on Jan 31, 2010

closeThis post was published 7 months 9 days ago which may make its actuality or expire date not be valid anymore. This site is not responsible for any misunderstanding.

gallery-preplus-102-300x222

gallery-pix-01-300x222

Last year, Palm took CES 2009 by storm introducing the Palm Pre and webOS. In November 2009, Palm introduced the Palm Pixi, a smaller, slightly less powerful brother to the Pre. Both were available on Sprint as their exclusive carrier. A year later at CES 2010, Palm introduced the Palm Pre Plus and the Palm Pixi Plus. Both devices brought some improvements and changes. Palm Pre Plus doubled the RAM (256MB – 512MB) so you can run more applications at once, and it doubled internal memory (8GB – 16GB) so you can store more photos, music, videos on the Pre Plus. They also redesigned the front of the Pre Plus, they removed the front button in favor of the Pixi-style gesture area. The Pixi Plus added Wi-Fi which was a huge complaint with the original Pixi. After using these phones for a couple of days, what do I think? Read on and find out.

Hardware
Screen shot 2010-01-31 at 9.48.01 PM
One of my main complaints about the original Pre was the build quality. I’m happy to report that on the Pre Plus, the build quality is so much more solid. No more creaks, there is nearly no play at all in the slider. Pixi Plus is solid, not a problem here.

The screen is bright and vivid, although the screen on the Pre Plus is noticeably brighter than the screen on the Pixi Plus. Just a quick recap, the screen on the Pre Plus is 320×480 resolution, it’s a capacitive touchscreen with multitouch capabilities. The screen is made out of hard plastic; still not as good as glass, but holds up fine. The Pixi Plus is 320×400 resolution, same capacitive + multitouch goodness.

Screen shot 2010-01-31 at 9.47.23 PM

Keyboard. I’m really, really picky about my keyboards. The Pre Plus keyboard is better than the one on the Pre, but still lacks the awesomeness found on the Pixi Plus. The keyboard on the Pixi Plus is a pure joy to type on. The keys are raised, have a great clicky feel to them. The one on the Pre Plus isn’t horrible, although the keyboard are much less clicky and because of the slider, it’s much less raised leading to a less perfect typing experience.

The gesture area works great on both devices, I definitely prefer the buttonless design over the one found on the Sprint Pre. The door that has access to the microUSB slot on the Pre Plus is still really flimsy. Overall, I’m happy that Palm really improved the overall quality of the hardware.

Software

The Pre/Pixi Plus is currently running webOS 1.3.5.1, which is identical to the software found on the Sprint Pre and Pixi. Palm said that webOS 1.4 will be available as an OTA update in February, so I’ll just go over the main features of webOS.

Unknown_2010-31-01_215814

After booting up the device, you’re presented with your wallpaper or choice and a dock. Each applications runs in a little window which Palm calls “Cards”. With these cards, you can run them in the background, all you do is swipe up from the gesture area, and you’re back out to your wallpaper, with the application running in a small window. Then you bring up the launcher again, and launch the next app, and the card you opened stays exactly the same. When you’re done with the app, just flick up and the app closes. To rearrange the cards, just hold down on the card and move it where you want. Depending on the amount of RAM in the device, the amount of apps or cards you run will vary. The Pre Plus can handle 50+ cards, Pixi Plus stopped at around 17 cards.

Unknown_2010-31-01_215855

Another cool feature is Synergy. It pulls in all your contacts, calendars, IM buddies, emails. It got really messy after I pulled in two Gmail accounts, because all the contacts, even people you just emailed once is in the contact list. Therefore, I don’t bother to use the Contacts app, I use Universal Search, another great feature Palm build in. How do you access Universal Search? Just start typing in Cards view, you can search your contacts, dial a number, or even search Google, Google Maps, Wikipedia, and Twitter.

browser_2010-31-01_220224

browser_2010-31-01_220458

The web browser in webOS is pretty good, especially since multitouch and double tap to zoom is included. Some of the heavy HTML sites didn’t render properly, some little things were slightly off.

findapps_2010-31-01_220419

findapps_2010-31-01_220447

The App Catalog on webOS is pretty small with only a handful of really good apps. The UI for the App Catalog is nice, the search doesn’t seem to work really well. For example when I search “Facebook”, it brought up a whole list of apps that have absolutely no connection to Facebook whatsoever, and the last listing was the actual Facebook app.

I love the Mobile HotSpot app. With that, I can tether my Pre/Pixi Plus to my laptop or any device that has Wi-Fi. I got good speeds, around 2-3Mbps. The Mobile HotSpot app is a battery drainer, after one hour of use, I lost about 40% battery life. The pricing for the Mobile HotSpot is $40 a month in addition to your data plan, and there is a 5GB cap. It’s relatively pricey, but it comes in handy sometimes.

Network and Call Quality

Verizon has great coverage, and the network was pretty stable where I am. For some reason, the Pre Plus would drop out of EV-DO every once in a while, which was kind of weird since the Pixi Plus didn’t do that. Call quality and both devices are great, the person I called said I sounded great, caller sounded pretty good on my end.

Pricing

The Pre Plus costs $149.99 with a new two-year contract and rebate. The Pixi Plus costs $99.99 with a new two-year contract and rebate.

Conclusion
Screen shot 2010-01-31 at 9.50.33 PM

Palm did make some improvements on the Pre Plus and the Pixi Plus. The bump in storage and RAM is welcomed, and the addition of Wi-FI on the Pixi Plus is also great. Battery life is a pretty big issue, and the device is not as speedy as some of it’s competitors, such as the Motorola DROID which is also on Verizon Wireless. I think webOS has great potential, I hope Palm will fix these issues in the next update of webOS.

Dan H. (85 Posts) - Website | Twitter | Facebook


Dan H. is a gadget lover. The computer is his mother tongue; he started using them since before he could remember. He specializes in mobile devices, and is nuts about any kind of new technology. Follow me on twitter: twitter.com/techshoe. Contact: dan (at) mobilitysite (dot) com

ADVERTISEMENT

  • jdiperla
    I have to say that I have used/owned several smartphones before including the Old PalmOS, Windows Mobile 2002/2003/5/6/6.1/6.5, Android, iPhone and Blackberry. And this is by far the most professional, funnest, most useful, most in-sync phone I have ever used!!!!!!!!!

    Palm has really done it. Their WebOS is amazing. I never ever experienced Multi-tasking as perfect as it is on this phone. Its really easy to use, even for beginners, and really fast and the idea behind it is just really simple. There is absolutely no flaw behind this system.

    The card system itself which allows the multi-tasking is really a cool feature. Atleast now I can pause my work wherever I am so that I can continue doing whatever else needs to be done. This innovation to me is comparable to when "Live DVR" was invented. Its truly that innovative.

    As far as apps go, there are nearly 3000 native apps available for it and more coming fast! Its not as many as the iPhone catalog, but you know what, atleast it doesn't have 345 different apps that do the same thing (EG: The lightsaber app on the iPhone. There are so many, but they all do the same stinking thing). Not to mention you can buy motionApps Classic and run all the old PalmOS Software, making the library really compete with the iPhone. And even though there arent as many "new" apps as the iPhone, there are tons of patches, updates and software and games that do EVERYTHING you need good enough. In fact, fewer apps even save you money in the long run.

    The Live syncing is amazing. All you do is put in your email address and/or facebook login and it does it all for you... It syncs all your calendars automatically. It syncs all your contacts automatically. And it syncs your inbox automatically. I have never experienced anything as effortless as this. It literally put all my information there for me. Putting this with the multi-tasking system makes doing business and mixing in pleasure a snap. The closest phone that matches this, I will say, is the iPhone. But the Pre is far superior in this aspect than the iPhone.

    The Launcher is cool too. You have the launch bar which can be dragged from top to bottom. Then the launcher itself which pretty much mimics the iPhones main launcher screen with several enhanced features which make it better.

    I like the music player and the support for ITunes, which most players do not have. So this is one of the few smartphone systems that can sync with ITunes on your pc and play your music. The original player was great. But I downloaded the free remix edition and it turned my Pre into the ultimate mp3 player ever!

    As far as hardware goes... I know many knock it. But, really, for a handheld, how much power do you need? 600mhz is not enough? You can even overclock it to 800mhz. It doesn't matter. The games play the same as they do on the iPhone (Trust me, I have played them on both), the smoothness of the interface is perfect. Really, what more do you want? Why pay more for better hardware that is really not needed on a handheld device? You want gaming power, buy a PSP or a DS. And still, it can probably play games just as well and poweful regardless.

    The Keyboard looks awkward at first, but is really nice and comfortable to use. And its a nice feature to have with a phone for messaging and e-mail and other things..

    It has 16gb of on device memory. What no 32GB???? Really, do you need that much anyway other than for music? I have about 25 hours of music on it. It only took up a little over a gig. For the rest of my music fixes, I use Pandora and radiotime- which more than cover up for the lack of an FM Player. In fact RadioTime plays over 50,000 stations in the US for free. I had every station I listen to on their. And as far as needing extra storage, the Pre is the first to offer Cloud Storage, meaning you can use ZumoDrive online to act as additional storage for the pre making it work as if it is actually part of the PRE. Its Awesome! I can virtually have unlimited space on the go with this thing. Not to mention that it also has a feature that backs up your whole phone onto Palm every day without ever interfering with your work. Why is this good? Because if you have to replace your phone, all you do on your next phone is login with your palm account and it restores ALL information and APPS so you dont lose a thing.

    The G-Sensor/Accelerometer works great. I used it with Need for Speed undercover and its perfect.

    The Camera works well and takes nice pictures.

    The screen quality... To me in actual display, graphics capabilities and color/brightness... ITS THE ABSOLUTE BEST. It has a 24bit graphics processor. Really, you cant go wrong with that. As far as touch sensitivity... OK. The iPhone is the best hands down. But, its good enough and is about 90% as good as the iPhone. Believe me, you would barely even notice the difference. And if you never had an iPhone before, you wouldn't know the difference. PERIOD.

    The design is really slick. I love it. Its not heavy. Its not bulky. The screen size is great. It could be a bit bigger, but its big enough. I never accidentally dial numbers with this thing. Its a pure genius design.

    People also complain about its sturdiness... I think its pretty sturdy. Otherwise buy an attractive case on ebay for $5 and thats it. But its definetly better than the Nexus one which will crack if you keep it in your pocket. Whats up with that?

    Other nice features of the pre:
    *Documents to go to view Excel, Word and PDF files.
    *Supports Facebook, Google, Exchange, IMAP and POP as well as AIM and other things.
    *For Developers it supports HTML5/CSS/Javascript or c/C++ with SDL and basically allows you to recompile any library thats available for linux so that you can port apps over easily. And you can actually use all these languages together!
    *Instant over the air updates of your apps
    *Great sound quality for phone calls.
    *3G phone. What would you really need 4G for? It streams music and video in HD really well already.
    *Palm really cares for its customers more than other companies. That puts this over the edge for that reason alone!

    The only downside to this is that battery. It consumes a lot of battery power. But just buy an extended battery, and it will last longer than any other phones battery, gaurantee'd!

    Try the Pre, you will not regret it. In fact you wont even go to another phone after this!!!!
  • Thanks for that. It sounds great. The only criticism is that you didn't mention whether you were talking about the Pre or Pixi until the second-to-last paragraph. :D

    The question is how long Palm can survive. The best products don't always win.

    Steve
  • why do they keep releasing devices with sub-vga resolution? that's like below SDTV, they should make vga the minimum standard especially now since we have WVGA and HWGA devices out.
  • Displays with more pixels probably have three negatives -- they cost more, they use more processor power (redrawing the screen means pushing more pixels) so the device is slower, and they eat more battery life (more transistors to power in addition to using more processor). In addition, there might be issues with software -- in the Windows Mobile world, lots of older software won't display properly on higher resolution displays without some tricks (pixel doubling, letter boxing, etc.).

    Not everybody needs VGA. I've been quite happy with my QVGA Windows Mobile devices. My Omnia is the first one that had a higher resolution.

    Steve
blog comments powered by Disqus

Subscription

You can subscribe by e-mail to receive news updates and breaking stories.

Polls

Would you use Bing on an iPhone?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

About Mobilitysite

Mobilitysite.com is a site covering Mobility News, Reviews, and Discussion. Our coverage focuses on Smartphones and PDAs, but extends on past that as well. Tablet PC, UMPC, and Personal Media Players like the Zune and iPod are covered as well. To learn more about Mobilitysite, read here. Also take time to register in our forums too. There is a wealth of information to be found inside. Mobilitysite has 0 RSS Subscribers.

Links

YouTube Twitter RSS Feed