|
You miss my point jwilker. Obviously ppc games are not going to compare favorably to PC games across the board. If I was suggesting that then no ppc game would get more than about a 3 or 4 out of 10. That was never the issue, though.
My point was, regardless of the platform being reviewed, that the top scores should be reserved for those special games that only come along rarely. Many average ppc games, albeit fun, are getting perfect or near perfect scores by ppc game review sites. If you give these scores to good games then there is nothing left to give to great games. My comparison to other platforms was only to state that they have matured to the point in their reviewing that their optimism and enthusiasm is balanced with reality and a faulty grading scale is not employed (for the most part).
I never said that I disliked the reviews. Quite the contrary, as a matter of fact. It is only the final scores that I am taking issue with.
Finally, you realize don't you that your logic that one cannot offer a critique on anything unless they first go out and do it themselves precludes you from ever offering your opion on just about everything. Never again comment on the reliability of your car or the performance of your computer, because afterall you have never built one yourself (presumably).
|