It's not a "better one", just a different thread about the same topic. Yes, I posted my opinion in the thread mentionned, but it was not started by me, and it has the opinion of many others people.
It would have been nice if the OS had support to switch "on the fly" between the two VGA modes, but hey, you cannot ask too much from MSFT, it took them 3 years to give us the Landscape mode :)