I’ve always loved adventure games.
I drooled when I saw the Magnetic Scrolls games on the Amiga when I went for the PC back in 1989 and couldn’t (then) afford an additional Amiga (those were really expensive back then!). I’ve read the reviews of Magnetic Scrolls games a lot and hoped the PC would receive text adventures like those.
Then came the Autumn of 1990 and the game Spellcasting 101 from Legend Entertainment. Man, what a game! A hi-res EGA (but it was pretty imporessive in hi-res CGA too!) game with beautiful, (in EGA) animated, hand-drawn graphics. That was the second game (next to Indy 500) that was clearly better than their Amiga counterparts (Legend hasn’t ported their games for the Amiga or other platforms, unfortunately.)
Legend has produced a lot of great, text-based adventure games after this, alongside with Lucasarts, who also started to mass-port their titles to the PC (or, to release their titles first for the PC and only after that to the Amiga) and Sierra.
(You may also want to read
this article on these games and running them on the PPC. The article was also published on the 22nd page of the July 2005
Pocket PC Magazine).
The Lucasarts games were immensely popular. They had much bigger popularity than games from Legend mostly because of their interface (which, from now on, will be referred to as the Lucasarts/Sierra interface) and their easier plot.
Unfortunately, the golden age of the Legend/Lucasarts/Sierra-type of adventures only lasted after, say, 1994-1995. After that, other types of games became the absolute stars. Real-Time Strategy (RTS) games (which isn’t particularly bad, after all – I loved, for example, Starcarft. Was even the 2nd in the national Starcraft championship
) and mostly First-Person Shooter (FPS) games. Also, beginning with the first, because of the sheer size of the multimedia contents, really CD-based game,
7th Guest, a new genre surfaced which, then, was also called Adventure: the puzzle games.
Also, adventures have changed a lot, especially starting with
Return to Zork from Infocom/Activision (I don’t need to introduce Infocom to any serious adventurer, I think
), in late 1993. A lot of them started having a First Person-view and full-screen graphics; even the adventures written by Legend started to have full-screen graphics from the year 1994.
In this roundup, I list and evaluate some of the new titles. Note that I also review puzzle games (which are, once again, can also be considered adventures) because of the lack of adventure games on the PPC. Please note that I haven’t reviewed the new
Egyptian Prophecy - The Fate of Ramses and some older titles like
Deja Vu I & II . I haven’t reviewed
ScummVM either, the best, multi-platform tool to run old Lucasarts games (you definitely want to give it a try!), because it’s not a game
per se.
Fade 1.09: the “Alpha and Omega” of Pocket PC adventures. Much as it’s almost 4 years old, it’s still the best “traditional” text-based adventure IMHO. It’s QVGA only, but, at least, it runs on current VGA devices too. It’s really worth giving a try.
Note that Fade has about 900 files in its subdirectories. This means you should never install it in the main memory, even if you have enough RAM, because of the
WinCE slowdown.
(A remark for people that (tried) to play earlier versions: this no longer crashes in the bedroom when you zoom in your wife’s clothes (a bug introduced by 1.03 and not eliminated until 1.06 AFAIK) when you pick up the train tickets.)
Interactive books from Inebooks: these interactive books, which have some resemblance with adventure games, are most likely well-known for RPG fans. Books like the games? interactive books? published/developed by this developer have been published by decades by other companies.
Therefore, their latest (and now-featured) title,
Dry Gulch (it was the one I’ve reviewed of their titles) is mostly meant for people that prefer “real” interactive books. For real adventure fans, they may be a big disappointment. Therefore,
try before purchase because they are a far cry from “real” adventures. Not even the images are clickable.
Atlantis Redux : a promising game with a First Person view. Its strength is that everything is spoken (and also subtitled for non-English speakers). If you like adventure games beloging to the FP genre, you’ll definitely like this.
Gilbert Goodmate
A definite killer along with Fade (or, for FP fans, Atlantis). A Lucasarts game clone. A must if you like traditional Lucasarts games!
Myst . Fans of the “puzzle” gender will definitely love this port. Die-hard (text/Lucasarts) adventure fans will not necessarily like this title, however.
Technically, it could be better – the Flash-based engine also results in a lot of restrictions. I wouldn’t want to comment on the game itself because I prefer text-based adventures and don’t particularly like puzzle games.
Some remarks for the summarization table
Memory occupation?: fortunately, all these games can be installed onto storage cards.
Mazes:
Traditional adventures often had mazes to increment the number of played hours and to make the player draw a map. For example,
Legend Entertainment’s Spellcasting 101 and 201 both had one; so did Gateway.
Sierra’s King’s Quest 5 is the same in this respect.
Much as the games mentioned (especially those developed by Legend Entertainment) have always been the best adventures, I personally dislike mazes. Fortunately, Fade doesn’t have mazes.
7th Guest-type of puzzles?
There is some difference between “real” adventures (of which, there’re two types: mostly text-based ones like Fade and Lucasarts/Sierra-like ones like Gilbert) and puzzle games that started with 7th Guest. Myst is more of the second category.
Native VGA?
Do the games offer native VGA capabilities? Unfortunately, only Myst have native VGA capabilities and
only while reading books (normally, it’s
QVGA only).
Text-based titles like Fade should be converted to VGA; these games would benefit a lot from this. Migration can’t be that complicated either because all the images in that game are ray traced and, therefore, can always be re-generated, now with a larger output resolution.
Hacking resistence - Not hackable gfx/sound file format: in these sections, I’ve examined the file format used by the game. If, for example, it’s very easy to get/extract sound/image files from the game (just like the case with Fade), then, the gamers can freely extract anything they like.
Hacking resistence - Not readable text format: it’s the best if the dialog text can’t be simply read with a file viewer in order to avoid cheating. (Once, when I got stuck with Spellcasting 101, I also started reading the not-really-encoded text in order to find out what to do
).
Speech with undertitles?: if there is spoken stuff in the game, is it (or, can it be) undertitled so that non-native speakers will also understand what’s going on? (Remember Return to Zork? It was very hard to understand for a non-native English speaker because of the very hih speech compression rate.) Fortunately, Atlantis excels at this; Myst, on the other hand, doesn’t.
You can find the summarizing table
here.
thanks 
