Voodoo3,
Li-Ion batteries can last about 300-400 cycles. If you have been charging the batteries every day, then you can count that the battery will last 300-400 days. If you do it every second day, then it doubles the lifespan. As you have had the batteries over 2-1/2 years, I would say that the batteries have reached their maximum usage and will need to be replaced. Your standard sized battery may not have had the charge cycles as high as the 1800mAh batteries and that is why it is still performing well. However, even with regular discharge I would expect that your standard battery will reach it life expectancy very soon as well.
If you need more information about Li-Ion batteries, please visit:
Welcome to Battery University
Mark
