imported_LorettaBoy

Just thought I would share my negative experience of using Belkin screen protectors on my new iPAQ.

These things are just horrible. I purchased a 12-pack of these at Futureshop up here in Canada. They are the "ClearScreen" type. And let me tell you, there is nothing clear about them! After applying several of the overlays I have come to the conclusion that they are just poor quality. I can't seem to apply them without getting a substantial "air bubble" effect. Also, they are very tough to remove from the screen. I tried the scotch tape trick, but good-luck, the adhesive on these things is ridiculous.

I will be ordering a new protector from Bando shortly. Hopefully it will arrive soon, because the Belkin makes the device so unattractive.

Anybody else had a bad experience with this brand of protector?

__________________

PDA Scrapyard: Casio 32k, Palm IIIe, Visor Deluxe, Palm V, Palm T2, Palm T3, iPAQ rx3115, iPAQ rx3715, iPAQ hx2750

swhoutx035

Originally Posted by LorettaBoy

Just thought I would share my negative experience of using Belkin screen protectors on my new iPAQ.

Sorry to hear about your bad experience with Belkin. I haven't tried them or Brando, but I have had execellent results with the ones from Boxwave.

harleyxlc

I haven't tried the Brando either, but they seem to get very good reviews. I have used the BoxWave and the WriteShield protectors, both with great results.

cwranger

I've been using the Belkin without any trouble. My experience has been that the small "air bubbles" work their way out over a few days. Also, when the device is on, you don't notice the air bubbles. I agree the adhesive is probably stronger than it needs to be.

len_dejesus

I've used both the Belkin and Boxwave - the difference is night and day - might as well put saran wrap on you PDA if you use the belkin ones. The Boxwave protector is so much better.

rob61280

Originally Posted by len_dejesus

I've used both the Belkin and Boxwave - the difference is night and day - might as well put saran wrap on you PDA if you use the belkin ones. The Boxwave protector is so much better.

yep the belkins I tried were turd, they had stripes on them that are not clear and they have belkin imbossed on the bottom of them


writeshield are a million times better
r

__________________
psion 3c --> palm IIIe --> Palm IIIc --> Phillips Nino (WinCE) -->h2210 -->h5555 --> x50v + mda Compact

mingkee

belkin is horrible
after about a week of use, a hole is formed up on the right bottom of scrolling bar (down arrow)
I use fingernail, but fellowes works ok, replace every 3-4 months, and a lot better than belkin
avoid "Clearscreen Overlay", period
don't tell me I never warned you

imported_CiscoKid

BoxWave all the way

__________________
Compaq C810 --> iPAQ h5450 --> Toshiba E800 --> HP hx4700

CEGiven

Today I removed my Belkin protector and put on a Boxwave. The Belkin brand was showing wear where I tapped the most, but was a decent protector FOR THE PRICE. They are a PAIN to put on (I usually ruin one or two getting them on), and it takes a week or so for the bubbles to dissapate. I always got bubbles no matter how careful I was. But they eventually disapper and as mentioned, they aren't as noticeable with the unit turned on.

In contrast, the Boxwave went on quickly, flawlessly, and easily! WOW! I used a can of compressed air before starting and ensured not a speck of dust was on the screen before applying. The Boxwave also has less glare. Definitely an impressive installation.

Loopee

I have also used the Belkin screen protector and would have to rate them as the worst accessary I have purchase for my iPaq.
The thing that annoyed me most is that here in Australia the Belkin brand is branded as an official HP product, It concerns me that HP would allow their name to be associated to such a crap product!

rEVOLVE

saran-wrap. . .hmmm. . .





syke! - Boxwave Cleartouch Crystals all the way, baby!!!

RED SEVEN

2 Thumbs up for my Boxwave!

I have never tried the Belkin and let me tell you why...I never buy or try anything without checking the forums here at IPAQHQ. I saves me money and hassles!

__________________

RED SEVEN
7

IPAQ HX 4700

fazwarts

Brando rocks

I used just one protector for over a year and the protector is still in perfect condition.

bigbrother

most of people here use Boxwave

imported_UrK

Brando protectors rock! Took a few days to arrive. Easy to attach, no bubbles, great sensitivity. Better view with direct sunlight.
And... I didn't mention the service yet.

__________________
Don't let your status to become to quo