X50 / X51 Forums - Talk about anything related to the X50 / X51 series.
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 04-01-08, 07:42 PM   #76 (permalink)
mousearoma
Aximsite Rookie
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 40
Location: United States
PDA: Dell Axim X30 High
iTrader Rating: (0)
Awards Showcase
Aximsite Contest Winner: Winners of a previous Aximsite Contest - Issue reason: Resco Keyboard winner 
Total Awards: 1
Thanks: 0
Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
View MyPDA
Originally Posted by rushnrockt View Post
I am struggling to understand what is it that this particular forum does that is illegal, as you claim? There is no downloading from this forum, so none of the objectionable software is present. So which laws are being broken?
I don't believe I ever (previously) explicitly stated I believe Chris' decision or the resulting discussion to be illegal, and I certainly did not state that in the excerpt you quoted. That except simply stated that the decision leads others to choose to download illegal ROMs.

However, at the very least the decision is, by my standards, unethical. In addition, I believe any resulting conversations in which members aid in the finding, downloading, and/or installing of illegal ROMs to be illegal. For instance, take New York's definition of 4th degree criminal facilitation:

Quote:
A person is guilty of Criminal Facilitation in the Fourth Degree when, believing it probable that he or she is rendering aid to a person who intends to commit a crime, he or she engages in conduct which provides such person with means or opportunity for the commission thereof and which in fact aids such person to commit a felony.
Now, I am not saying that any of this constitutes a '4th degree count of criminal facilitation' in NY or elsewhere. I am simply using that as a generic example of a legal definition of the term "facilitation." However, telling others where to, and how to, download/install illegal ROMs certainly meets that general definition, and facilitation, in most jurisdictions, is a crime in and of itself. (Exact definition, qualifications, etc. vary.)

So, I argue the decision is unethical while the resulting conversations between members is facilitation.

John
__________________
mousearoma is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote

Old 04-01-08, 08:00 PM   #77 (permalink)
JKooL
Aximsite Rookie
 
JKooL's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 37
Location: Illinois
PDA: Axim x51v
iTrader Rating: (0)
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
View MyPDA
Originally Posted by mousearoma View Post
However, telling others where to, and how to, download/install illegal ROMs certainly meets that general definition, and facilitation, in most jurisdictions, is a crime in and of itself. (Exact definition, qualifications, etc. vary.)
John
It most certainly does not meet the definition. In order for the crime to have been committed, it must be proven that intent existed in the mind of the suspect at the time the assistance was provided.

Furthermore, it is a very broad interpretation of "rendering aid" to include posting on an internet forum.

Because someone asks how they can do something, does not prove intent that they plan to do it.
__________________
Me: "I just finished encoding 2 DivX files to watch on my PDA!!"
Friend: "Sweet, now you can watch movies without having to worry about any of those 'discernable details'."
JKooL is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote

Old 04-01-08, 08:43 PM   #78 (permalink)
Martin
Aximsite Consultant
 
Martin's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 2,887
Location: U.K.
PDA: x50v/x51v
Phone: HTC Touch Dual
Laptop: XPS M1330
iTrader Rating: (0)
Thanks: 4
Thanked 9 Times in 7 Posts
View MyPDA
Originally Posted by mousearoma View Post
I don't believe I ever (previously) explicitly stated I believe Chris' decision or the resulting discussion to be illegal, and I certainly did not state that in the excerpt you quoted. That except simply stated that the decision leads others to choose to download illegal ROMs.

However, at the very least the decision is, by my standards, unethical. In addition, I believe any resulting conversations in which members aid in the finding, downloading, and/or installing of illegal ROMs to be illegal. For instance, take New York's definition of 4th degree criminal facilitation:

Now, I am not saying that any of this constitutes a '4th degree count of criminal facilitation' in NY or elsewhere. I am simply using that as a generic example of a legal definition of the term "facilitation." However, telling others where to, and how to, download/install illegal ROMs certainly meets that general definition, and facilitation, in most jurisdictions, is a crime in and of itself. (Exact definition, qualifications, etc. vary.)

So, I argue the decision is unethical while the resulting conversations between members is facilitation.

John
I don't think any half-decent lawyer would argue that people who engage in discussion on where to/how to download WM6 will be subject to criminal sanctions. I certainly wouldn't, anyway.

It is far more likely that the copyright holders will seek to protect their works (under the Berne Convention or the relevant applicable domestic law), and issue a C&D notice to the person hosting the files or (and I think this extremely unlikely) hosting the discussions.

As to ethics, I have already made our position clear:

Quote:
To my mind, at no point in the process have any decisions been taken on the basis of morality. It has been about legality, and business efficacy. Those who point to the contradictory nature of our change in stance are, to my mind, missing the point - Aximsite has never sought to impose some kind of communal morality on its members [although we have tried to keep the forums safe for kids, and thus banned certain topics]. As long as it is legal, and it will not potentially affect the future of the site, then we will allow it. Those two requirements have now been satisfied.
I think this discussion has more or less run its course. The decision as been made, and made in what we feel are the best interests of our members. Those few that disagree with the policy are welcome to ignore all threads relating to WM6 ROMs.
__________________
___________________________
Martin is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote

Old 04-01-08, 08:44 PM   #79 (permalink)
Eric12341
Aximsite Veteran
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 1,548
Location: Zion,IL
PDA: Axim X51v Wm6 A03
iTrader Rating: (0)
Awards Showcase
Aximsite Active Bronze Member: Given to all active members (1 year and over 750 posts) - Issue reason: Active Member 
Total Awards: 1
Thanks: 0
Thanked 3 Times in 3 Posts
View MyPDA
I wonder if all the closed threads are re-opened now
Eric12341 is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote

Old 04-01-08, 09:24 PM   #80 (permalink)
mousearoma
Aximsite Rookie
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 40
Location: United States
PDA: Dell Axim X30 High
iTrader Rating: (0)
Awards Showcase
Aximsite Contest Winner: Winners of a previous Aximsite Contest - Issue reason: Resco Keyboard winner 
Total Awards: 1
Thanks: 0
Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
View MyPDA
Originally Posted by JKooL View Post
Furthermore, it is a very broad interpretation of "rendering aid" to include posting on an internet forum.
--> Broad interpretation as written into law by the State of New York as well as many others. Internet postings are not explicitly included, but they are not excluded either. In fact, websites, MySpace pages, and forum postings have all been used as evidence of intent and/or commission of crimes, so it is not far-fetched for such to be counted as a form of facilitation.


Originally Posted by JKooL View Post
Because someone asks how they can do something, does not prove intent that they plan to do it.
--> Very true. However, if someone actually does commit the crime that they asked for help in planning then you have facilitated the crime. The point is you don't know whether or not the other person has the intent to commit the crime, which is why if someone asks you how to kill a spouse and make it look like an accident you don't start listing poisons that don't turn up in autopsies.
__________________
mousearoma is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote

Old 04-01-08, 10:10 PM   #81 (permalink)
rlarson_mn
Aximsite Veteran
 
Join Date: Nov 2005
Posts: 2,173
Location: Minnesota
PDA: X51V WM6.1 L11 Beta
Phone: Razr V3M
Carrier: Verizon
Laptop: Dell D620
PMP: iPod Photo 60gb
iTrader Rating: (0)
Awards Showcase
Aximsite Active Bronze Member: Given to all active members (1 year and over 750 posts) - Issue reason: Active Member 
Total Awards: 1
Thanks: 0
Thanked 21 Times in 19 Posts
View MyPDA
Originally Posted by mousearoma View Post
--> Broad interpretation as written into law by the State of New York as well as many others. Internet postings are not explicitly included, but they are not excluded either. In fact, websites, MySpace pages, and forum postings have all been used as evidence of intent and/or commission of crimes, so it is not far-fetched for such to be counted as a form of facilitation.




--> Very true. However, if someone actually does commit the crime that they asked for help in planning then you have facilitated the crime. The point is you don't know whether or not the other person has the intent to commit the crime, which is why if someone asks you how to kill a spouse and make it look like an accident you don't start listing poisons that don't turn up in autopsies.
This guy said to me 'They just found a 1000 lawyers at the bottom of that lake over there, do you know what they call that'? I said 'No I guess I don't. To which he replied 'A good start'!

Last edited by rlarson_mn : 04-01-08 at 10:12 PM.
rlarson_mn is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote

Old 04-01-08, 10:11 PM   #82 (permalink)
mousearoma
Aximsite Rookie
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 40
Location: United States
PDA: Dell Axim X30 High
iTrader Rating: (0)
Awards Showcase
Aximsite Contest Winner: Winners of a previous Aximsite Contest - Issue reason: Resco Keyboard winner 
Total Awards: 1
Thanks: 0
Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
View MyPDA
Originally Posted by Martin View Post
I think this discussion has more or less run its course. The decision as been made, and made in what we feel are the best interests of our members.
While no common ground or reversal was found in this thread, at least it was clarified that the decision was made in the interests of those who wish to download/use illegal ROMs, not in the interest of ethics, morals, or the spirit of the law. Personally, I believe the future of society is bleak if decisions continue to be made upon covetousness rather than temperance and a sense of right and wrong. Regardless, I agree the discussion has more or less run its course as no common ground can be found, and will now take my leave from this thread.

John
__________________
mousearoma is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote

Old 04-02-08, 03:22 AM   #83 (permalink)
Kevin1a
Aximsite Major League
 
Kevin1a's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 334
Location: Colorado Springs, CO
PDA: Axim x51v
Phone: RAZR
Carrier: ATT
Laptop: HP Pavillion
PMP: WMP and TCPMP
iTrader Rating: (1)
Awards Showcase
Aximsite Contest Winner: Winners of a previous Aximsite Contest - Issue reason: Review Winner 
Total Awards: 1
Thanks: 15
Thanked 11 Times in 10 Posts
View MyPDA
I guess I can come out of the closet now. I flashed every ROM between WM5 A017 and the brand spanking new WM6.1! If there was a legal upgrade, I would purchase it, even if I continued to use hacked ROMS, simply because it would be the right thing to do. I can honestly say that it will take a LOT of software and firmware development to outgrow the X51v hardware, and I am not going to let some moneygrubbing corperation sell me a new device until they exceed the specs of my old device. That said, WM6 for the Ax has gotten better and better.

Chris, I appreciate your decision, and I think the no-hosting rule is good. It keeps Aximsite (the entity) seperate from Aximsite (the users) and will certainly help us avoid trouble if any were to come our way (unlikely if you look at how long XDAdevs has been chilling, and doing what they do)
__________________
Did I answer your question or make a meaningful contribution to the discussion? Press my "thanks button" (in the lower right hand corner) to say thanks!
Kevin1a is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote

Old 04-02-08, 07:09 AM   #84 (permalink)
Martin
Aximsite Consultant
 
Martin's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 2,887
Location: U.K.
PDA: x50v/x51v
Phone: HTC Touch Dual
Laptop: XPS M1330
iTrader Rating: (0)
Thanks: 4
Thanked 9 Times in 7 Posts
View MyPDA
Originally Posted by mousearoma View Post
While no common ground or reversal was found in this thread, at least it was clarified that the decision was made in the interests of those who wish to download/use illegal ROMs, not in the interest of ethics, morals, or the spirit of the law. Personally, I believe the future of society is bleak if decisions continue to be made upon covetousness rather than temperance and a sense of right and wrong. Regardless, I agree the discussion has more or less run its course as no common ground can be found, and will now take my leave from this thread.

John
I'll make this even more simple, so everything is very clear.

1) To the best of our knowledge, what Aximsite/Mobilitysite is doing is not against the law (phrases like "spirit of the law" are vague and unhelpful).

2) We are not about to enter into a debate on descriptive ethics. It is up to individual members whether or not they want to download, install or discuss such ROMs. It is not mandatory. We are simply allowing that discussion if it does take place. The choice, as it were, is yours.

3) Your rhetoric seems fairly divorced from reality. A large majority of Axim users have already installed WM6 on their device. It seems trite to point out that we are, in practice, doing a greater disservice to members by disallowing discussions altogether than we are by lifting that ban. Aximsite is the place for how to use, or fix, your Axim. How can that be maintained if the majority of users (and almost all power users) are using a platform that cannot be discussed in the forums?

4) As for your sweeping statement,

Quote:
Personally, I believe the future of society is bleak if decisions continue to be made upon covetousness rather than temperance and a sense of right and wrong.
What a load of nonsense. If we take your "argument" to its logical conclusion, then surely it is the members' decision making processes that will be in issue here. If everyone makes decisions on the basis of "temperance and a sense of right and wrong", then it would follow (according to your logic) that there would be no discussion of WM6 on Aximsite. I fail to see how our policy could be equated with a moral floodgates argument. Are you seriously suggesting that because we have provided a forum for WM6 discussions, we are intrinsically responsible for the decision that each person makes to participate in such discussions? If you are, then on that view I would agree: the future is bleak. If we assume, however, the people are not automatons, and can assume responsibility for their own actions, then your argument is fallacious.
__________________
___________________________
Martin is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
The Following User Says Thank You to Martin For This Useful Post:
m.baurmann (04-03-08)

Old 04-02-08, 01:07 PM   #85 (permalink)
DJUnreal
Aximsite Minor League
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 181
Location: Behind you...
PDA: Axim X51v WM6
Phone: Nokia 6300
PMP: Zen Vision:M 60Gb
iTrader Rating: (0)
Thanks: 0
Thanked 3 Times in 3 Posts
View MyPDA
Well, I gotta say I'm glad I'm allowed to talk about WM6.1 now
DJUnreal is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote

Old 04-02-08, 01:19 PM   #86 (permalink)
radimus
Aximsite Elite
 
radimus's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 4,324
Location: Tampa
PDA: Cingular 8525
Phone: Cingular 8525
Carrier: Cingular US
Tablet: Compaq tc4400
Laptop: Latitude d520
PMP: Cingular 8525 /w WMP
iTrader Rating: (0)
Awards Showcase
Aximsite Bronze Contributors: For Members that have donated more than $10 to the website - Issue reason:  Top Notch MyPDA: Given to the best MyPDAs out there! - Issue reason: Excellent MyPDA! News Editor Medal: Aximsite News Editors Past and Present - Issue reason: MobilitySite News Editor/Contributor Aximsite Veteran Staff: Given staff members who have given their time to Aximsite 3+years! - Issue reason: MobilitySite for 3 Years Aximsite Silver Reviews: Members that have posted 5 Review Threads. - Issue reason: Confirmed that user has posted five (5) Reviews Aximsite Bronze Referrer: Users that have referred at least 2 members. - Issue reason: Referred 2 Members per profile log Aximsite Active Bronze Member: Given to all active members (1 year and over 750 posts) - Issue reason: Active Member Aximsite Active Silver Member: Given to all active members (3 years and over 1,500 posts) - Issue reason: Active Member w/3 Years & 3000+ Posts 
Total Awards: 8
Thanks: 5
Thanked 31 Times in 30 Posts
View MyPDA
I heard a radio "talking head" say something to the effect of, "If you allow lawyers to run your business, your business is doomed"

The angle he aimed at was that a lawyers job is typically to minimize (legal) risk and as such is always in fear of exposing the business to "risk". However, RISK is what allows a business to take a chance and succeed. The most appropriate method for managing corporate lawyers is to inform them of the direction the business is to go and for them to "Find a way to make it happen"

Obviously much of that is to be taken with a grain of salt, but the concept is to take a reasonable chance and not to fear POSSIBLE or POTENTIAL repercussions... PROBABLE and LIKELY repercussions are another issue...
__________________
Quote:
"Always vote for principle, though you may vote alone, and you may cherish the sweetest reflection that your vote is never lost." -- John Quincy Adams
My Articles and My News

Software Discounts for MobilitySite members and Aximsite Store

How to Ask Questions the Smart Way and Before you Ask

radimus is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote

Old 04-02-08, 02:17 PM   #87 (permalink)
ursoouindio
Aximsite Rookie
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 76
Location: Porto Alegre - Brazil
PDA: X51v WM6.1, beta6 "puré"
iTrader Rating: (0)
Thanks: 3
Thanked 3 Times in 3 Posts
View MyPDA
i've always understood the site policy about wm6.x but I am now glad that this discussion is opened and I agree with the idea that the site should support users who want to take the best from their Axims. Wm6 is an advance to the axims and been not supported by M$ or Dell just hinder the development and what remains to users is only the informal communication.

What I would suggest is a new section to the site, since the new discussions would take a huge place, for sure.

I did not upgraded to wm6 yet, but I am considering for quite a while, just didn't got the time to read enough about it. I guess I will post my major doubts right away here!
ursoouindio is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.us